The Conscience on the Fence
Pastor Nick Gatzke

Picture a fence between two farms. It marks a boundary because the two properties are not the same. They have different owners, different crops, and different systems. By climbing over to one side or the other you enjoy the benefits and submit to the rules of that side. But there is another option, and it is the one many of us quietly prefer. You can sit on the fence enjoying the view of both fields while not committing to either side.
While that may sound safe, it’s a dangerous place to stay.
Sitting on the fence is not neutrality but indecision; and indecision eventually demands a decision. Some people spend a lifetime dangling their feet on both sides when it comes to God. They are trying to figure out: Must I submit to God? Can I enjoy the fringe benefits? Can I have it my way and his way at the same time?
A Family Trait
In Mark 6, we are introduced to a man who spent years perched right there. Fence-sitting ran in the family. Herod Antipas’ father, Herod the Great, was a Jew who governed the Jewish provinces for Rome—ruling his own people against their will for the benefit of their conquerors. Herod Antipas inherited a quarter of that territory and, though only a tetrarch, he insisted on being called king.
Herod had also taken Herodias, the daughter of one half-brother and the wife of another, making her both his niece and his sister-in-law. While most religious leaders feared him and allowed Herod’s behavior to pass, John the Baptist would not, saying plainly, “It is not lawful for you to have your brother’s wife” (Mark 6:18). As a result, Herodias was humiliated and furious. So Herod, stuck in the middle between John and Herodias, had John arrested—which also conveniently quieted the crowds John was drawing into the wilderness.
Fascinated and Furious
John was all in. He lived in the wilderness, ate locusts, and wore clothes made from camel’s hair. He called people to repent and declare total allegiance to the kingdom of Heaven. Mark writes, “Herod feared John, knowing that he was a righteous and holy man, and he kept him safe. When he heard him, he was greatly perplexed, and yet he heard him gladly” (Mark 6:20). What a strange description. Herod imprisoned John, but protected him. He was unsettled by John, but enjoyed him.
This is what holiness does to people. Rudolf Otto wrote The Idea of the Holy, a study of how people across many cultures respond to the sacred. Holiness, Otto concluded, is mysterium tremendum—impossible to fathom yet undeniably powerful. Everywhere he looked the reaction was the same. People expressed conflicting feelings. Holiness both fascinates and repels at once.
That was Herod’s reaction. He would summon the prisoner to his chamber to talk about God and repentance and this Jesus he kept hearing about. Herod would be perplexed, think on it, and change nothing—then come back days later with another question and walk away again.
Too Much to Lose
So why not repent? Because repentance had a price tag. Herod’s status would change. His marriage would have to end. His opulence would be threatened. He preferred the stimulation of holiness to the surrender of it—access to the conversation without submission to the truth. So he kept John alive and went on living his own way.
Then came his birthday. Nobles, commanders, and the leading men of Galilee filled the hall, while wine and music flowed late into the night. Herodias had been waiting for this. She sent her teenage daughter out to dance for the guests, and when the girl finished, the room erupted. Herod swore an oath in front of everyone saying to the girl, “Ask whatever you wish, up to half my kingdom.”
She consulted her mother, and the answer came back chilling and calculated. She demanded the head of John the Baptist on a platter. Immediately, Mark tells us, “the king was exceedingly sorry, but because of his oaths and his guests he did not want to break his word to her” (Mark 6:26). Herod had a moment to do the right thing, and judged it too expensive. The man Jesus called the greatest born of women was executed in a basement to protect a king’s reputation at a party.
Herod never planned this, of course. He liked having things both ways. But the fence always comes down somewhere. If you do not yield to Christ, you will yield to your sin. If you do not turn from your sin, your sin will turn you in. This is the tension in all of us.
Herod turns up once more in Scripture a year or two later. Luke records, “When Herod saw Jesus, he was very glad… he questioned him at some length, but he made no answer” (Luke 23:8–9). Again, Herod wanted an amusement, not God. And Jesus would not speak a word to him. A conscience that was once open to God was now closed.
The Invitation Still Stands
So where are you? Are you sitting on the fence, or planted firmly inside God’s domain? Is there ground in your life not yet surrendered to Christ, some sin you hope to keep while keeping the benefits of God too? Is he compelling you to move while you keep resisting?
You cannot stay on the fence forever. But here is the good news: God is gracious. He is quick to forgive. And he is still inviting you down onto his side of the fence.
“A Word From Pastor Nick” is based on Pastor Nick Gatzke’s Bible teaching on A BETTER WORD.