Latest Episode

Money and Allegiances, Pt. 1

Nick Gatzke
Date 11/17/26
Book Mark
0:00

Click HERE to access this program’s Study Guide

You see it every election cycle—two people quoting the same Bible to prove opposite points, each one certain the Almighty voted the way they did. It’s an old habit. Pastor Nick Gatzke examines the true motivation behind a seemingly straightforward question two opposing groups brought to Jesus and how his response exposed their true allegiances


I want to ask you to grab a Bible with me and open to the Gospel of Mark, chapter 12. Mark 12 is found on page 848 of the Pew Bible. And as you turn, let me pray. Father, we ask now that you would bless the reading and the preaching of your most holy word, that you would continue to reveal yourself by it, that you would encourage us through it, that you would convict us. And Lord, that you would ultimately continue to change us. We ask this for our good and your glory.

Amen.

There are only two things that are certain in life. Death and taxes. Most everyone has heard that famous quote from Ben Franklin coined many, many years ago. Ben Franklin had been a member of the Constitutional Convention of 1787, and at the age of 81, had attended every single session. And after the Constitution was ratified by the individual states, Franklin wrote a letter to a colleague of his in France, updating him on the State of the Union. And in the letter, he said, “our new Constitution is now established. Everything seems to promise it will be durable. But in this world, nothing is certain except death and taxes.” Over 200 years later, we’re thankful that we have a constitution that’s still alive. And we all certainly still face death. And we all pay more in taxes than Ben Franklin and his buddies would have stood for.

But the question about death and taxes far predates the time of Franklin and certainly our time. And today we’re going to look at the first of three consecutive accounts of religious leaders that are coming to test Jesus. Remember where this fits in the storyline of the gospel of Mark. Jesus is in Jerusalem. He’s teaching in the temple. He’s condemned the religious leaders. He has announced the end of the temple system. Many are following him. Some thinks he’s crazy. The religious leaders see him as a threat and they want to kill him. And now in the middle of all of that, they want to ask him about taxes.

And so let’s hear what he says. Mark chapter 12. starting at verse 13. “And they sent to him some of the Pharisees and some of the Herodians to trap him in his talk. And they came to him and said, “teacher, we know that you are true and do not care about anyone’s opinion, for you are not swayed by appearances, but truly teach the way of God. Is it lawful? To pay taxes to Caesar or not? Should we pay them or should we not?” But knowing their hypocrisy, he said to them, “why put me to the test? Bring me a denarius and let me look at it. And they brought one. And he said to them, whose likeness and inscription is this? And they said to him, Caesar’s. Jesus said to them, Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s and to God the things that are God’s.” And they marveled at him.”

You see, the Herodians and the Pharisees were two groups of leaders into Israel that had no love for each other. They looked at the situation and they considered what was best for Israel. And they came to opposite conclusions of how to get there. You might describe the Herodians as Roman sympathizers. It was a political class that gained their name because they were aligned with King Herod and later his descendants. And they supported the occupation of the Roman Empire in Israel, even though they were Jews themselves. And they attempted to show their support to the Roman rulers and thus gain power for themselves while garnering their support in return. And this made them rather flexible. about their religious beliefs. They weren’t primarily interested in following the Old Testament law of God, but rather they were interested in political stability. So they were willing to compromise on matters of conviction for a more pragmatic outcome. Now you might imagine this didn’t make them particularly popular with many of the Jews because they collaborated with the Romans. And the fact that Jesus was in the middle of this whole situation and was becoming rather political in his intonation made him a threat to this political class of people.

If the Herodians were the Roman collaborators, the Pharisees were the Jewish nationalists. Their primary concern was religious fidelity. And they sought to follow the Old Testament law and lead the common people of Israel to do the same. And as a result, they had tremendous influence as religious leaders. They were no fans of the Romans. They thought that Israel should govern itself according to the law of God as outlined in the Old Testament. And as a result, they found no love for the Herodians either. So if you think about the Herodians, being the liberals, and the Pharisees being the conservatives, and both the liberals and the conservatives coming together for a unified purpose, this unified purpose was to get rid of Jesus. And so they set the trap.

But first, they have to butter him up a little bit. So it says in verse 14, “they came and they said to him, teacher, we know “that you are true and do not care about anyone’s opinion, for you’re not swayed by appearances, but truly teach the way of God. Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar or not? Should we pay them or should we not?” So now you see the setup. If Jesus agrees that it’s morally lawful to pay taxes to the Roman emperor, then the Pharisees will regard him as a Roman sympathizer and put him among the liberals. But if he says that it’s morally unlawful to pay taxes to Caesar, the Herodians will point to him as an insurrectionist and a political rebel.

And if he remains silent and says nothing, then they will all regard him as evasive. And not really desiring to teach the things of God, but caring more about what other people think. They got him. right where they want him on this one. Surely there’s no escape.

And so it says in verse 15, “knowing their hypocrisy, he said to them, why do you put me to the test? Bring me a denarius and let me look at it. And they brought one. And he said to them, whose likeness and inscription is this? And they said to him, Caesar’s. Jesus said to them, render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God, the things that are God’s. And they marveled at him.”

You see, the coin that Jesus asked for is a denarius, which is what the people were required to give as the imperial poll tax. For the privilege of breathing the air of the Roman Empire, they would be taxed this amount, which was about a one day’s wage. And on the coin, is an inscription, Tiberius Caesar Divi Augusti Filius Augustus, which means Tiberius Caesar Augustus, son of the divine Augustus. And on the reverse side, bore an image of Tiberius’s mother, Livia, with the inscription Pontifex Maximus, or high priest. And as Jesus gazes at the coin that they give him, and he looks over the image of Tiberius Caesar, and as he reads the inscription, displays political genius, a saying that we repeated the world over millions of times by now. Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s and render to God that which is God’s.

You see, in the ancient world, It was assumed that the coins were the property of the person whose image and inscription was on them. The coin belonged to Caesar. And so Jesus is, in essence, saying, well, the coin belongs to Caesar, give it back to him. And who could argue with that? But then comes the kicker, and give to God the things that are God’s. And now you start to see how this very short interaction, a trap with a brief response begins to apply to us because what Jesus is talking about here is allegiance.

Allegiance. Allegiance means loyalty and support. Allegiance presumes that you have a hierarchy or a rank order of your loyalty. Allegiance assumes that if you are loyal to some things, that necessarily means that you can’t be loyal to other things. And he is reminding us that our greatest allegiance is to God. But it begs a question, this idea of allegiance, as we walk through our life and we think about our loyalty and our support, and we think about where the rank order of those priorities are, Where does allegiance fall with regard to the government?

It’s interesting that Jesus’ response didn’t simply call Caesar out as a false ruler of this government or a sham government that was obtained by military occupation. In a sense, he actually validated the government as legitimate, and he points to our civic duties in it. And that’s consistent, actually, with the rest of the teachings of Scripture. Romans 13.1 says, “let every person be subject to the governing authorities, for there’s no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God.” Likewise, in 1 Peter 2, verses 13 to 17, he tells

all of the… who are in exile and under persecution to submit to the government institutions above them for the Lord’s sake. And then he… It goes on to explain how the Lord uses them to punish the wicked and praise those who do good. Elsewhere in Scripture, you see that there are occasions to disobey the government, to be sure, and that principle of civil disobedience, of which we could have a much larger conversation about, can be summarized very simply this way. It’s right to disobey the government or exercise civil disobedience if the government forbids what God commands or if The government commands what God forbids. And we see examples of that in this scripture as well.

But then you see in 1 Timothy 2, the sentiment or the heart of the Christian toward the government. When Paul writes to Timothy, “I urge that supplications, prayers, intercessions, and thanksgivings be made for all people, for kings, And all who are in high positions, that we may lead a peaceful and quiet life, godly and dignified in every way.” And so we see that through submission and even a certain type of allegiance to our government, that that is something that’s good. God puts rulers in place. God in his providential care directs human history. in ways that sometimes we can’t see and can’t understand in the moment, but we’ll all come together in due course.

It’s good to love your country. I certainly love ours. It’s good to want the very best for your country, especially insofar as those desires are achieved through righteous means or noble purposes. It’s good to have allegiance to your country, even when times… are difficult. But for Christians, this is not the highest of our allegiances. There is an implication for allegiance and for the self. Render unto Caesar’s what is Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s, Jesus says. And if the logic that he uses, that the coin belongs to Caesar, because it’s got his image on the front of it and his inscription on it, therefore it belongs to him, then we must ask the question, what has the image of God imprinted on it?

You, you are imprinted with the image of God. The coin belongs to Caesar. People belong to God. You remember, don’t you? Genesis 1:27, “so God created man and woman in his image. In the image of God, he created him. Male and female, he created them.” You know, in the past 10 days, we had another baby born at Old North Church. Well, not in the building, thankfully. And I love the fact that we have so many little kids running around this place and babies back there in the nursery. Picture in your mind for a minute the face of a newborn baby. It’s innocent gaze. And you catch a glimpse of something sacred, the divine image imprinted upon every human soul. And unlike the denarius, which bears Caesar’s likeness, you look at the coin, it kind of looks like him, kind of not.

We bear the image of God himself. And Jesus urges us to recognize that profound reality. Render to God the things that are God. Our primary allegiance is not to an earthly authority. It is to the almighty creator who formed us in his likeness. Just as the coin belongs to Caesar because it bears the image, so too do our lives belong to God because we bear his image.

Our allegiance to God then is shown in how we give ourselves to him. Now, there’s a lot of ways to explore what it means to express allegiance because we bear the image of a God. There’s a lot of ways to express that allegiance by giving ourselves to him. How do we bear God’s image in such a way that we communicate, that we live? in allegiance, loyalty, support, devotion to him. Foster the right type of love. Jesus says in Matthew 22, as people address him with the question, teacher, what is the great commandment in the law?

And he said to them, “you shall love the Lord your God with all of your heart and with all of your soul and with all of your mind. This is the great and first commandment.” And this love that he talks about is a love that you foster. If you have an interest in something, let’s just say golf, and you start spending time practicing and then playing golf, your interest will grow into passion. And golf is very weird because you could take 80, 90, 100 shots, and 98 of them could be terrible, but it’s just the two that create the passion. If you have an interest in a person and you spend time with that significant other, your interest grows into love.

And actually, for those of you who’ve been married for a number of years, you probably realize that in some ways, because of your time and intention and love for your spouse, they have actually changed you and you’ve become more like them in certain ways. And they have become more like you in certain ways as well. The same is true with God. Affections are fostered. for him through time and intentionality, you can foster your love for God. This is why we encourage very basic disciplines like reading your Bible and praying every day, going to a growth group and spending time in community around God’s word, attending a Sunday school class, serving in some way, time and intentionality with God and the things of God foster your love for him. And your allegiance to him grows as your love for him fostered.

###

 

This transcript was generated using AI transcription technology and reviewed for accuracy, but may contain errors. Please refer to the original audio for precise wording.

 

Follow Nick